--- title: SEC Mulls Rule 605 Reform description: The price-time requirement might not be enough anymore. image: https://articles.marketsmedia.com/hubfs/Imported_Blog_Media/iStock-911582060-May-12-2022-08-46-44-35-AM.jpg --- ![websites-group](https://articles.marketsmedia.com/hubfs/raw_assets/public/MarketsMedia_August2021/images/new-MMG-01.svg) [![](https://articles.marketsmedia.com/hubfs/raw_assets/public/MarketsMedia_August2021/images/dropdown-new-marketsmedia-logo.svg)](https://www.marketsmedia.com/) [![](https://articles.marketsmedia.com/hubfs/raw_assets/public/MarketsMedia_August2021/images/dropdown-menu-traders-redlogo.svg)](https://www.tradersmagazine.com/) [![](https://articles.marketsmedia.com/hubfs/raw_assets/public/MarketsMedia_August2021/images/dropdown-menu-bestexe-logo.svg)](https://www.bestexecution.net/) [![](https://articles.marketsmedia.com/hubfs/raw_assets/public/MarketsMedia_August2021/images/dropdown-menu-fidesk-logo.svg)](https://www.fixglobal.com/) [![](https://articles.marketsmedia.com/hubfs/raw_assets/public/MarketsMedia_August2021/images/dropdown-fixglobal-new-logo.svg)](https://www.fixglobal.com/) - [*Facebook*](https://www.facebook.com/MarketsMedia/) - [*Twitter*](https://twitter.com/marketsmedia) - [*Linkedin*](https://www.linkedin.com/company/markets-media-llc) - [Newsletter](https://articles.marketsmedia.com/sec-mulls-rule-605-reform#popup-newsletter) #### Want the latest news on securities markets -- FREE? Sign up to receive exclusive articles on topics including: - Equity market structure - Profiles of buy-side investment firms - The evolution of multi-asset-class trading - Regulation and its implications for markets - The search for liquidity in fixed income markets - The convergence of fintech and capital markets Select one or more newsletters you would like to receive: menu [![Markerts media](https://articles.marketsmedia.com/hubfs/raw_assets/public/MarketsMedia_August2021/images/header%20logo.svg "Markerts media")](https://articles.marketsmedia.com/) - [Weekly Newsletter](https://articles.marketsmedia.com/tag/weekly-newsletter) - Weekly Newsletter - SEC Mulls Rule 605 Reform Search - [Home](https://articles.marketsmedia.com/) - [Trending](https://articles.marketsmedia.com/tag/trending) - [Featured](https://articles.marketsmedia.com/tag/daily-email-feature) - [Sectors](https://articles.marketsmedia.com/tag/sectors) - [From The Markets](https://articles.marketsmedia.com/tag/from-the-markets) - [AWARDS](https://articles.marketsmedia.com/tag/events) - [Newsletter](https://awards.marketsmedia.com/newsletter-sign-up) - [Newsletter](https://articles.marketsmedia.com/sec-mulls-rule-605-reform#popup-newsletter) Hide search Search - NewsLetter ![](https://articles.marketsmedia.com/hubfs/Imported_Blog_Media/trading-up-occ-iex-select-board-members-citadel-lands-lieblich-573x379-Jul-07-2022-09-34-11-57-AM.jpg) [ON THE MOVE: Citi Hires Artie Ambrose;...](https://articles.marketsmedia.com/on-the-move-citi-hires-artie-ambrose-natalie-a-brown-to-mesirow) ![](https://articles.marketsmedia.com/hubfs/Imported_Blog_Media/Depositphotos_445735906_L.jpg) [Trading Adapts to ESG and Sustainable...](https://articles.marketsmedia.com/trading-adapts-to-esg-and-sustainable-investing) ![](https://articles.marketsmedia.com/hubfs/Imported_Blog_Media/iStock-917493152-Jul-07-2022-09-34-19-09-AM.jpg) [Focus on FX Execution Connectivity](https://articles.marketsmedia.com/focus-on-fx-execution-connectivity) ![](https://articles.marketsmedia.com/hubfs/Imported_Blog_Media/Depositphotos_333839538_L.jpg) [TRACE Turns 20](https://articles.marketsmedia.com/trace-turns-20) 09.19.2019 By Rob Daly Weekly Newsletter # SEC Mulls Rule 605 Reform 09.19.2019 By Rob Daly ![SEC Mulls Rule 605 Reform](https://articles.marketsmedia.com/hubfs/Imported_Blog_Media/iStock-911582060-May-12-2022-08-46-44-35-AM.jpg) [Share](https://www.facebook.com/share.php?u=https://articles.marketsmedia.com/sec-mulls-rule-605-reform) [Tweet](https://twitter.com/intent/tweet?text=US+ETFs+Have+Record+Net+Inflows&url=https://articles.marketsmedia.com/sec-mulls-rule-605-reform) [Share](https://www.linkedin.com/cws/share?url=https://articles.marketsmedia.com/sec-mulls-rule-605-reform) U.S. Securities and Exchange Commissioner Elad Roisman stirred the market-structure pot by floating potential reforms to the regulator's best execution requirement at SIFMA's annual market structure conference in Midtown Manhattan. He cited his concerns that brokers are substituting a focus on price, time, and the avoidance of trade-throughs for robust best execution analysis. "Price is cut and dry, but it is just one factor in best execution analysis when firms make routing decisions and when regulators review those decisions," said Commissioner Roisman. One possible approach would be to expand the definition to include subjective factors. "The SEC has previously cited many other aspects of a brokers' routing decisions in obtaining best execution of customer orders," he said. "These include size, availability of information, trading characteristics for a security, transaction costs, and ease of getting a fill. Going beyond the SEC, FINRA cites several other factors surrounding best execution, including price improvement, opportunities, the difference in price dis-improvement, the likelihood of execution of limit orders, customer needs and expectations, and the existence of internalization or payment-for-order-flow arrangements." To enable such a change, the Commission could consider adopting a non-prescriptive interpretation of Regulation NMS' Rule 605 in which brokers would have a baseline requirement that would apply across various market niches and market conditions. Brokers would then be able to differentiate themselves by performing beyond the baseline. New best execution requirements likely would require the Commission to review or even eliminate its Order Protection Rule as well. "When adopting NMS 14 years ago, the Commission could not have had predicted 13 active equities exchanges with a 14th recently approved and two more in the works as well as 30 alternative trading systems," he noted. The Commissioner raised multiple ways in which the SEC could update the Order Protection Rule, including having exchanges meet a set average daily volume level during a set period, adjusting round lot sizes based on price or order size, or protecting the smaller exchanges. "I'm not committed to any of these, but are using them to spur the conversation," said Commissioner Roisman before turning his focus towards order management systems. He questioned whether the recent consolidation within the OMS market and the opacity of the platform providers' pricing had raised risks for investors and brokers and if they were diligently overseeing their relationship with the vendors and their services. "They are performing services that market participants value and have become interwoven in the equities environment," he said. "I would like to understand this thread that runs through the equities market better." [Share](https://www.facebook.com/share.php?u=https://articles.marketsmedia.com/sec-mulls-rule-605-reform) [Tweet](https://twitter.com/intent/tweet?text=US+ETFs+Have+Record+Net+Inflows&url=https://articles.marketsmedia.com/sec-mulls-rule-605-reform) [Share](https://www.linkedin.com/cws/share?url=https://articles.marketsmedia.com/sec-mulls-rule-605-reform) ![email](https://articles.marketsmedia.com/hubfs/Markets%20Media/email.svg) ### NEWSLETTER SIGN UP And receive exclusive articles on securities markets ### Related articles 1. [![](https://articles.marketsmedia.com/hs-fs/hubfs/Imported_Blog_Media/EMCA-WINNERS.jpeg?width=376&height=250&name=EMCA-WINNERS.jpeg)](https://articles.marketsmedia.com/european-markets-choice-awards-2022-the-winners) Latest News ## [European Markets Choice Awards 2022 – The Winners](https://articles.marketsmedia.com/european-markets-choice-awards-2022-the-winners) On 5 June Markets Media held its first in person European Markets Choice Awards event in London. 07.06.2022 By Markets Media 2. [![](https://articles.marketsmedia.com/hs-fs/hubfs/Imported_Blog_Media/trading-up-occ-iex-select-board-members-citadel-lands-lieblich-573x379-Jul-07-2022-09-34-11-57-AM.jpg?width=376&height=250&name=trading-up-occ-iex-select-board-members-citadel-lands-lieblich-573x379-Jul-07-2022-09-34-11-57-AM.jpg)](https://articles.marketsmedia.com/on-the-move-citi-hires-artie-ambrose-natalie-a-brown-to-mesirow) Daily Email Feature ## [ON THE MOVE: Citi Hires Artie Ambrose; Natalie A. Brown to Mesirow](https://articles.marketsmedia.com/on-the-move-citi-hires-artie-ambrose-natalie-a-brown-to-mesirow) The weekly recap of new hires, promotions and job changes in capital markets trading and technology. 07.05.2022 By Anna Lyudvig, Traders Magazine 3. [![](https://articles.marketsmedia.com/hs-fs/hubfs/Imported_Blog_Media/339299_345359258874293_1089957387_o.jpg?width=376&height=250&name=339299_345359258874293_1089957387_o.jpg)](https://articles.marketsmedia.com/summer-trading-2012-10-years-on) Latest News ## [Summer Trading 2012, 10 Years On](https://articles.marketsmedia.com/summer-trading-2012-10-years-on) A look back at a Markets Media event from a decade ago. 07.05.2022 By Traders Magazine [![MarketsMedia](https://articles.marketsmedia.com/hubfs/MarketsMedia.svg "MarketsMedia")](http://marketsmedia.com) - [About us](https://www.marketsmedia.com/about-us) - [Careers](https://www.marketsmediagroup.com/careers) - [Contact](https://www.marketsmediagroup.com/contact) - [Advertise](https://www.marketsmediagroup.com/advertise) - [Newsletter](https://awards.marketsmedia.com/newsletter-sign-up) - [Corporate Site](https://marketsmediagroup.com) - © 2026 Markets Media Holdings LLC - - Terms & Conditions - Privacy Policy {{ standard\_footer\_includes }}