--- title: "OPINION: Mistakes Were Made" description: Can regulators fix the bond-liquidity mess they helped create? image: https://articles.marketsmedia.com/hubfs/Imported_Blog_Media/iStock-507120525-1.jpg --- ![websites-group](https://articles.marketsmedia.com/hubfs/raw_assets/public/MarketsMedia_August2021/images/new-MMG-01.svg) [![](https://articles.marketsmedia.com/hubfs/raw_assets/public/MarketsMedia_August2021/images/dropdown-new-marketsmedia-logo.svg)](https://www.marketsmedia.com/) [![](https://articles.marketsmedia.com/hubfs/raw_assets/public/MarketsMedia_August2021/images/dropdown-menu-traders-redlogo.svg)](https://www.tradersmagazine.com/) [![](https://articles.marketsmedia.com/hubfs/raw_assets/public/MarketsMedia_August2021/images/dropdown-menu-bestexe-logo.svg)](https://www.bestexecution.net/) [![](https://articles.marketsmedia.com/hubfs/raw_assets/public/MarketsMedia_August2021/images/dropdown-menu-fidesk-logo.svg)](https://www.fixglobal.com/) [![](https://articles.marketsmedia.com/hubfs/raw_assets/public/MarketsMedia_August2021/images/dropdown-fixglobal-new-logo.svg)](https://www.fixglobal.com/) - [*Facebook*](https://www.facebook.com/MarketsMedia/) - [*Twitter*](https://twitter.com/marketsmedia) - [*Linkedin*](https://www.linkedin.com/company/markets-media-llc) - [Newsletter](https://articles.marketsmedia.com/opinion-mistakes#popup-newsletter) #### Want the latest news on securities markets -- FREE? Sign up to receive exclusive articles on topics including: - Equity market structure - Profiles of buy-side investment firms - The evolution of multi-asset-class trading - Regulation and its implications for markets - The search for liquidity in fixed income markets - The convergence of fintech and capital markets Select one or more newsletters you would like to receive: menu [![Markerts media](https://articles.marketsmedia.com/hubfs/raw_assets/public/MarketsMedia_August2021/images/header%20logo.svg "Markerts media")](https://articles.marketsmedia.com/) - [Weekly Newsletter](https://articles.marketsmedia.com/tag/weekly-newsletter) - Weekly Newsletter - OPINION: Mistakes Were Made Search - [Home](https://articles.marketsmedia.com/) - [Trending](https://articles.marketsmedia.com/tag/trending) - [Featured](https://articles.marketsmedia.com/tag/daily-email-feature) - [Sectors](https://articles.marketsmedia.com/tag/sectors) - [From The Markets](https://articles.marketsmedia.com/tag/from-the-markets) - [AWARDS](https://articles.marketsmedia.com/tag/events) - [Newsletter](https://awards.marketsmedia.com/newsletter-sign-up) - [Newsletter](https://articles.marketsmedia.com/opinion-mistakes#popup-newsletter) Hide search Search - NewsLetter ![](https://articles.marketsmedia.com/hubfs/Imported_Blog_Media/trading-up-occ-iex-select-board-members-citadel-lands-lieblich-573x379-Jul-07-2022-09-34-11-57-AM.jpg) [ON THE MOVE: Citi Hires Artie Ambrose;...](https://articles.marketsmedia.com/on-the-move-citi-hires-artie-ambrose-natalie-a-brown-to-mesirow) ![](https://articles.marketsmedia.com/hubfs/Imported_Blog_Media/Depositphotos_445735906_L.jpg) [Trading Adapts to ESG and Sustainable...](https://articles.marketsmedia.com/trading-adapts-to-esg-and-sustainable-investing) ![](https://articles.marketsmedia.com/hubfs/Imported_Blog_Media/iStock-917493152-Jul-07-2022-09-34-19-09-AM.jpg) [Focus on FX Execution Connectivity](https://articles.marketsmedia.com/focus-on-fx-execution-connectivity) ![](https://articles.marketsmedia.com/hubfs/Imported_Blog_Media/Depositphotos_333839538_L.jpg) [TRACE Turns 20](https://articles.marketsmedia.com/trace-turns-20) 05.25.2017 By Rob Daly Weekly Newsletter # OPINION: Mistakes Were Made 05.25.2017 By Rob Daly ![OPINION: Mistakes Were Made](https://articles.marketsmedia.com/hubfs/Imported_Blog_Media/iStock-507120525-1.jpg) [Share](https://www.facebook.com/share.php?u=https://articles.marketsmedia.com/opinion-mistakes) [Tweet](https://twitter.com/intent/tweet?text=US+ETFs+Have+Record+Net+Inflows&url=https://articles.marketsmedia.com/opinion-mistakes) [Share](https://www.linkedin.com/cws/share?url=https://articles.marketsmedia.com/opinion-mistakes) The first step is to admit that there's a problem and The Federal Reserve Bank of New York has recognized that, somewhat. The authors of a recent post on its *Liberty Street Economics* blog noted that in its attempt to protect and stabilize the markets after the 2008 financial crisis, the resulting regulation has had "an adverse impact on bond-level liquidity." The authors concluded that the more leveraged systemic institutions and those institutions "that are more akin to investment banks" have switched roles regarding providing liquidity to the corporate bond market with the latter providing less liquidity than they did previously. \[broadstreet zone="58119"\] I'm sure that most institutional investors are happy that the New York Fed's research has reached the same conclusion that the buy side has witnessed since the crisis. But are there any actual investment banks left? Once Goldman Sachs applied for its New York banking license in December 2008, I thought of it as the death knell of the dedicated investment banking industry. The investment bank's capital raising functions migrated to their regular banking counterparts while hedge funds took over their roles of market makers. I doubt that the politicians and regulators who developed and implemented the Dodd-Frank Act, MiFIDs I & II spent much time thinking about the knock-on effects of their radical market structure changes would have when the markets returned to "normal" conditions. As a result, dealers tend to keep only the most liquid issues on their balance sheets, which leaves asset managers warehousing the majority of the market's corporate bond inventory. Institutional investors would love to set the clock back so that market participants can play the roles of which they are the most familiar. Just like trying to un-ring a bell, this is never going to happen. No politician has the moral courage to repeal the market reforms and face the ensuing encounters of angry populists armed with torches and pitchforks. The most practical, but slowest, thing to do is to wait for the generational turnover in the asset management community and have portfolio managers and traders who are willing to use new methods to find liquidity. The industry already is seeing this in the adoption of electronic trading. According to recent Greenwich Associates research, 37% of global fixed income's notional volume trades electronically. Adoption of electronic trading only will grow as more second-tier and boutique dealers that specialize in less-liquid issues begin participating on these platforms. Electronic trading, however, is just a baby-step in fixing the inventory imbalance. The greatest challenge will be getting institutional investors to accept the all-to-all trading methodology. Right now, asset managers are willing to trade with other asset managers as long as they are not the price maker. Whether that derives from their clients' charters or simply the fear of defending trading decisions to the firm's board and regulators, asset managers as a whole aren't doing it. Until pension funds unshackle the asset managers' hands and allow them to be price makers, all-to-all trading will never have a chance to rebalance bond inventories and the industry will be stuck with the status quo. [Share](https://www.facebook.com/share.php?u=https://articles.marketsmedia.com/opinion-mistakes) [Tweet](https://twitter.com/intent/tweet?text=US+ETFs+Have+Record+Net+Inflows&url=https://articles.marketsmedia.com/opinion-mistakes) [Share](https://www.linkedin.com/cws/share?url=https://articles.marketsmedia.com/opinion-mistakes) ![email](https://articles.marketsmedia.com/hubfs/Markets%20Media/email.svg) ### NEWSLETTER SIGN UP And receive exclusive articles on securities markets ### Related articles 1. [![](https://articles.marketsmedia.com/hs-fs/hubfs/Imported_Blog_Media/EMCA-WINNERS.jpeg?width=376&height=250&name=EMCA-WINNERS.jpeg)](https://articles.marketsmedia.com/european-markets-choice-awards-2022-the-winners) Latest News ## [European Markets Choice Awards 2022 – The Winners](https://articles.marketsmedia.com/european-markets-choice-awards-2022-the-winners) On 5 June Markets Media held its first in person European Markets Choice Awards event in London. 07.06.2022 By Markets Media 2. [![](https://articles.marketsmedia.com/hs-fs/hubfs/Imported_Blog_Media/trading-up-occ-iex-select-board-members-citadel-lands-lieblich-573x379-Jul-07-2022-09-34-11-57-AM.jpg?width=376&height=250&name=trading-up-occ-iex-select-board-members-citadel-lands-lieblich-573x379-Jul-07-2022-09-34-11-57-AM.jpg)](https://articles.marketsmedia.com/on-the-move-citi-hires-artie-ambrose-natalie-a-brown-to-mesirow) Daily Email Feature ## [ON THE MOVE: Citi Hires Artie Ambrose; Natalie A. Brown to Mesirow](https://articles.marketsmedia.com/on-the-move-citi-hires-artie-ambrose-natalie-a-brown-to-mesirow) The weekly recap of new hires, promotions and job changes in capital markets trading and technology. 07.05.2022 By Anna Lyudvig, Traders Magazine 3. [![](https://articles.marketsmedia.com/hs-fs/hubfs/Imported_Blog_Media/339299_345359258874293_1089957387_o.jpg?width=376&height=250&name=339299_345359258874293_1089957387_o.jpg)](https://articles.marketsmedia.com/summer-trading-2012-10-years-on) Latest News ## [Summer Trading 2012, 10 Years On](https://articles.marketsmedia.com/summer-trading-2012-10-years-on) A look back at a Markets Media event from a decade ago. 07.05.2022 By Traders Magazine [![MarketsMedia](https://articles.marketsmedia.com/hubfs/MarketsMedia.svg "MarketsMedia")](http://marketsmedia.com) - [About us](https://www.marketsmedia.com/about-us) - [Careers](https://www.marketsmediagroup.com/careers) - [Contact](https://www.marketsmediagroup.com/contact) - [Advertise](https://www.marketsmediagroup.com/advertise) - [Newsletter](https://awards.marketsmedia.com/newsletter-sign-up) - [Corporate Site](https://marketsmediagroup.com) - © 2026 Markets Media Holdings LLC - - Terms & Conditions - Privacy Policy {{ standard\_footer\_includes }}