Morgan Stanley and Goldman Sachs both reported large increases in trading revenues for the second quarter of this year, adding to the strong trading results reported by JP Morgan and Citi.
Today Morgan Stanley reported record net revenues of $13.4bn (€11.7bn) for the second quarter ended June 30, compared with $10.2bn a year ago, which the firm said reflected contributions from all businesses and geographies.
Institutional Securities’ net revenues for the quarter increased 56% to a quarterly record of $8bn. Sales and trading contributed $5.6bn in net revenues, up 68% from a year ago, which the firm said was due to strong client engagement as markets stabilized.
Institutional Securities' revenues. Source: Morgan Stanley.
James Gorman, chairman and chief executive, highlighted the performance of fixed income on the results call. He said the decade-long business transformation of the business model was intended to provide stability during times of serious stress and proved its worth in the second quarter.
James Gorman, Morgan Stanley
Gorman said on the call: “We made cuts to fixed income in the fourth quarter of 2015 to enormously de-risk and reduce large illiquid positions. We decided the business needed to make revenues of $1bn each quarter in order to survive and, as it has consistently delivered, the target has gone up to $1.5bn each quarter.”
Fixed income sales and trading earned revenues of $3bn in the second quarter of this year. The firm said the increase in credit products reflected robust global capital markets activity and credit spread movements. Foreign exchange and rates benefited from elevated volatility and wider bid-offer spreads while commodities also benefited from higher client activity in volatile markets.
Jonathan Pruzan, chief financial officer of Morgan Stanley, said on the results call that fixed income sales and trading had its highest revenues for more than a decade. He added: “Cash equities sales and trading had historic volumes and derivatives had the highest revenues in a decade driven by client activity.”
Goldman Sachs reported yesterday that net revenues in Global Markets were $7.18bn for the second quarter of 2020, 93% higher than a year ago.
Fixed income, currency and commodities generated quarterly net revenues of $4.24bn, its highest quarterly performance in nine years, which the bank said reflected continued strong client activity in intermediation and financing.
Stephen Scherr, chief financial officer of Goldman Sachs, said on the results call that FICC had significantly higher net revenues across all major businesses, particularly in interest rate products, credit products and commodities.
Equities sales and trading
Pruzan continued that equities sales and trading at Morgan Stanley earned revenues of $2.6bn in the second quarter. He said: “Cash equities had historic volumes while derivatives had the highest volume in a decade.”
At Goldman Sachs equities sales and trading generated quarterly net revenues of $2.9bn, its highest quarterly performance in eleven years which was driven by both cash products and derivatives.
Global markets revenues. Source: Goldman Sachs.
Jamie Dimon, chairman and chief executive said on the JP Morgan results call this week that trading revenues were likely to fall by half in the second half of this year.
David Solomon, chairman and chief executive of Goldman Sachs, said on the results call: “No-one knows the exact direction of trading in the second half of the year. Activity in March and April was extraordinary and has slowed, but volumes in June were higher than in 2019 and 2018.”
Capital markets
Pruzan said underwriting at Morgan Stanley had the strongest revenues in a decade. Equity capital markets activity has accelerated in the last two months due to the increase in initial public offerings, secondaries and record convertible bond issuance.
Jonathan Pruzan, Morgan Stanley
“In debt capital markets, global high-yield issuance set a record in June,” added Prozan. “Investment grade issuance also reached record as companies bolstered their balance sheets.”
Investment banking at Goldman Sachs generated record quarterly net revenues of $2.66bn, including record quarterly net revenues in both equity and debt underwriting.
Remote working
Gorman said the Morgan Stanley results build on the momentum of a very strong first quarter while more than 90% employees were working from home. However, he added that the bank was unlikely to change its real estate presence in large financial centres.
“We are committed to major cities such as New York, London, Frankfurt, Tokyo and Hong Kong and that has not changed,” he added. “We may look at our business continuity plan and capacity across our branches to add more flexibility.”
David Solomon, Goldman Sachs
Solomon said there were benefits to people working together so staff were returning, dependent on local conditions. In Hong Kong 50% of staff have returned to the office, in Europe 35%, in the UK 15% and a small group in New York.
“It is not business as usual as staff wear masks and there are safety protocols,” he added.
Goldman Sachs’s total net revenues were $13.3bn, 41% higher than the second quarter of 2019, and the firm’s second highest quarterly net revenues.
